Dark Autumn vs Dark Winter: How to Tell the Difference

Dark Autumn and Dark Winter (also called Deep Autumn and Deep Winter) are neighbours on the color wheel. Both have deep coloring and both look powerful in rich, dark shades. That is exactly why people swap between them. The good news is that one question settles it: does your coloring lean warm or cool?

What the two seasons share

  • Depth is the main feature. Hair and eyes are usually dark, and skin can be anywhere from light to very deep.
  • Both look best in deep, saturated colors rather than pastels.
  • Both can handle stronger contrast than the soft or light seasons.

The difference in one line

Dark Autumn is deep and warm, with an earthy, slightly muted richness. Dark Winter is deep and cool, with a crisp, jewel-like clarity. Dark Autumn looks like a forest in October; Dark Winter looks like a night sky with jewels in it.

Five quick tests

  • Neutrals: compare dark chocolate with true black. Chocolate looking richer points to Dark Autumn; black looking sharper points to Dark Winter.
  • Whites: compare ivory with optic white. Ivory flatters Dark Autumn; optic white flatters Dark Winter.
  • Greens: compare olive with emerald. Olive suits Dark Autumn; a cool emerald or pine suits Dark Winter.
  • Lipstick: brick or warm brown-red suits Dark Autumn; deep berry or blue-red suits Dark Winter.
  • Metals: antique gold and bronze suit Dark Autumn; silver and platinum suit Dark Winter.

Do the tests in daylight with no makeup. If three or more point the same way, you have your answer.

Contrast is one of the easiest traits to misjudge. The personal contrast test checks it in five questions.

Side-by-side palettes

  • Dark Autumn: chocolate, espresso, burgundy, brick red, burnt orange, mustard, forest green, olive and deep teal.
  • Dark Winter: black, charcoal, pure white, burgundy, true red, emerald, pine green, navy, royal purple and fuchsia.

Dark Autumn

  • Chocolate#5C3A21
  • Brick red#9C3D2E
  • Burnt orange#B8541B
  • Mustard#C79A1E
  • Olive#5E6B2E
  • Forest green#2E5939

Dark Winter

  • Black#141414
  • Pure white#FAFAFA
  • True red#C8102E
  • Emerald#00704A
  • Royal purple#4B2C82
  • Fuchsia#C2185B
Dark Autumn vs Dark Winter palette comparison: chocolate, brick red, burnt orange, mustard, olive, forest green versus black, pure white, true red, emerald, royal purple, fuchsia
Save this comparison or pin it for later. Download the comparison image (PNG)

Burgundy appears in both, which is a good clue. If you look great in burgundy but cannot decide on the rest, use the neutral and white tests above, because they show the warm and cool difference most clearly.

Makeup and hair

Dark Autumn looks best in bronze, copper and olive eyeshadow, warm brick lips and chocolate liner. Dark Winter looks best in charcoal, plum and silver eyeshadow, berry or blue-red lips and crisp black liner. For hair, Dark Autumn suits chocolate, mahogany and deep auburn, while Dark Winter suits espresso, soft black and cool dark brown.

Common mistakes that cause the mix-up

  • Judging by hair alone. Dark hair is common to both seasons, so it cannot decide between them.
  • Testing under warm indoor lights, which push almost everyone toward Dark Autumn.
  • Assuming deep skin must be warm. Many people with deep brown skin have cool undertones and are Dark Winter.
  • Choosing by favourite colors. Liking black does not make you a Winter; look at what your skin does next to it.

A starter wardrobe for each season

For Dark Autumn, build around espresso or chocolate trousers, a camel or olive coat, cream knitwear, and a few rich accents such as burgundy, rust or deep teal. For Dark Winter, build around black or charcoal trousers, a navy or black coat, crisp white shirts, and jewel-tone accents such as emerald, royal purple or true red. Either way, a burgundy piece is a safe first buy while you are still deciding.

Build more combinations from any of these shades with the color harmony generator.

What if you sit between them?

Some people are close to the line, often with neutral or olive undertones. In that case, stay with the colors both palettes share: burgundy, deep teal, navy and dark charcoal. Then lean warm or cool depending on the outfit and your jewelry.

See the full palettes

The Deep Autumn guide and the Deep Winter guide each have 12 hex codes, outfit combinations, makeup and hair colors. Not sure you are a deep season at all? Try the free color analysis quiz or the what season am I quiz.

Curious what your own season is?

Take the free quiz โ†’

Keep Reading